facebook feed fist header movement-text refugee-movement-text twitter youtube
international woman space

Bundestag Passed the new asylum law. What will change?

Threat of expansion of Deportation detention: Law for the Right to stay and termination of the residence permission adopted.

On the 2nd of July the Bundestag adopted the redefinition of the right to stay and the termination of the residence permit. Parts of the law shows the intention of making the lives of those already residing in Germany better. At the same time legal opportunities will be created to act more rigorously against newly arrived asylum seekers. An overview of the changes and its consequences:

Grounds for detention in the Dublin procedure will be limitless

The new law creates the legal possibility to detain asylum-seekers for the sole reason that they entered Germany from another EU country. According to Chapter 15, paragraph 2, sentence 2, makes an arrest on Dublin grounds possible “when a foreigner leaves a member state before the conclusion of the asylum application process or the application for international protection”. This will mean that the majority of asylum seekers falling under the Dublin III Regulation, can be taken into custody. This acts against the Dublin III Regulation, where it is stated that one cannot be arrested because of a Dublin-procedure.

Also particularly worthy of criticism is the reason for imprisonment described in §2, Chapter 14, number 4, after which a foreigner may be detained for paying large sums of money to a smuggler (§96 of the Residence Act) for his/her unauthorized entry.

How can people seeking protection enter Germany, without a so-called smuggler when legal means are largely cut off? Since 1980, Germany has systematically introduced the visa requirement for all countries of origin of asylum seekers. This was accompanied with the creation of sanctions for transport companies. Refugees cannot simply legally travel to Germany. They won’t get a visa. They depend usually on smugglers to be able to seek refuge in Europe.

PRO ASYL fundamentally criticizes the detention of asylum seekers in Dublin procedures. Detention is a totally inappropriate measure against people seeking protection. In addition, a large proportion of asylum seekers are traumatized or, for other reasons, are particularly vulnerable – in these cases prison is above all unacceptable.

Right to stay for those who have Duldung for several years

The hypocritical approach of the past, to solve the problem of long term Duldung holders by giving a right to stay for everybody who applied before a specific date (Stichtag) some years before, is over. The new regulation to get a right to stay independently from a “Stichtag” is welcomed.

People living for several years in Germany will now be given the chance to finally acquire a secured residence. Even though there are still huge obstacles with integration and language learning, many of the Duldung holders will be able to benefit from the provisions of the Residence regulations.

People fulfilling following conditions can get a right to stay according to §25b:

– having stayed as a family with underage children for at least six years in Germany

– Residing without underage children for at least eight years in Germany

– Possess a minimum knowledge of German A2 and secure their livelihood by working primarily or those who will be likely to do so in the future. However, these conditions are not to be applied to those who can’t work because of age, illness or disability.

– have revealed their identity, presented a passport or shown the effort by presenting such documents and didn’t fulfill the criteria for deportation according to § 54.

It is positive that the life subsistence of the asylum seeker does not have to be already secured for granting or renewal time. The securing of the life subsistence of those with Duldung is currently a major problem because in some parts of Germany the remaining bans on asylum seekers exclude them from the labor market despite the liberalization of the employment law (see § 33 BeschVO).

This has statistically detectable consequences: in 2010 only 11% of Duldung holders were employed in Germany, according to a study of the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees’ called: “Immigrants in the low-wage sector with special attention to Duldung holders and those allowed to stay”.

It is unfortunate that this law, like the ones before, has a long list of exceptions.

At least it is not based on past misconduct. Excluded from accessing the right to stay are only those who still don’t fulfill the obligation to cooperate.

On the negative side, family reunification is now absolutely impossible. Even after years, the people who received a residence permit through § 25b don’t have the right to have their spouses brought to Germany. This is not acceptable, since the protection of marriage and the family must also apply to those who reside here permanently.

Improved right to stay for pupils – only partial protection from deportation during education

The existing residence permit to young Duldung holders under § 25a of the Residence Act has improved. The right to stay will be granted after four years, instead of six years, for those residing and attending school in Germany. This is positive. However, the regulation will still be unnecessarily restricted by rigid age limits. Namely, the right to stay for well-integrated young people (§ 25a) shall be granted only if they have attended school for four years before their 21st birthday.

This has problematic consequences: many unaccompanied minors will not benefit from the right to stay, since most of them are already 17 years old. From the general provisions on residence rights for the well-integrated, they can only benefit if they have lived at least eight years in Germany (§ 25b). The consequence: young people will be stuck with Duldung, the most precarious status for integration because it makes much more difficult for potential employers to invest in training for example.

In addition to this change, there are negotiations within the big coalition to give a right to stay for people in educational training, which means a long term Duldung (§ 60a para. 2) instead of a proper residence permit. The training must start before they reach the age of 21 years. And the person must not be a former asylum seeker whose country of origin is on the list of “safe countries of origin”. That means, once again refugees from the Western Balkan countries are excluded.

At least the Duldung for those under Training last for a long period. But this cannot hide the fact that it does not create any right of residence. For many employers Duldung status gives a deterring signal. Often Duldung holders will not get the training in the first place. Those who really want to give young people a chance to integrate, must give them a proper residence permit!

New re-entry bans would criminalize West Balkan refugees

The new regulation, which allows the Federal Office to issue an entry and residence ban (§ 11 para. 7) to rejected asylum seekers coming from “safe-country of origin” is a further intensification which is directed against the West Balkan refugees. After the big coalition was established in 2014, with the approval of the Bundesrat in disregard of the massive human rights deficit in the countries of the Western Balkans, a discriminatory special treatment in the asylum procedure, there is now a further threat of discrimination.

If asylum seekers from Serbia, Bosnia-Herzegovina and Macedonia are provided EU-wide with an entry ban, this accompanies fatal politics of at least two of these countries (namely Serbia and Macedonia). Roma will be particularly prevented to leave and will be interrogated and sanctioned when they are sent back/deported because of allegedly “illegal” stay abroad or supposedly provision of false declarations.

This trend is reinforced by the effects of the new § 11 Chapter 7 according to which the person concerned will receive a EU-wide entry ban and be intercepted at the EU’s external borders of Hungary or Bulgaria. Those who still manage to come to Germany will be threatened with a sanction by the criminal codex. Whoever enters bypassing visa bans can be prosecuted. This regulation will lead to a completely disproportionate criminalization of those affected.

Custody for those awaiting Deportation: constitutionally questionable

Custody for those awaiting deportation, which as an instrument has had hardly any practical relevance in the past recent years, will now be revived through various measures.

One of the most problematic aspects is the introduction of the so-called exit custody: if a collective deportation is planned, people can be imprisoned for four days without the usual constitutional requirements (existence of special grounds for detention). This is not compatible with European law and constitutional law.

The law doesn’t need approval by the Bundesrat. The hearing in the Bundesrat expected for the beginning of July will only be a formality. An exact date for the law entry into force is not yet known.

Translated by International Women Space from the Original text published by Pro Asyl.


international woman space

international woman space

Video: Emergency shelter in Wiesenstraße throws out Syrian refugee woman at night

Klick HERE for the Press Release which was published few days ago. Watch the video: https://vimeo.com/154353396 International Women Space got to know Viviana when she was still living the emergency shelter (Lager) at the Wiesenstraße, in Wedding, Berlin. On te 29th of January we went to the Notunterkunft to have a coffee with Viviana and… Read more »

vivianapic
international woman space

IN OUR OWN WORDS Book launch

Refugee Women in Germany tell their stories WHEN: 19.00 | 25th November 2015 WHERE: TheaterSpielRaum, Bethanien-Südflügel, Mariannenplatz 2B, 10997 Berlin   In 2013, we, the activists from International Women Space (IWS), set ourselves the task of documenting the lives and stories of refugee women in Germany. We approached the project in the Latin American tradition of… Read more »

In our own words

Featured

berlin news / News

Demo 10.12. Keine Abschiebungen nach Afghanistan!تظاهرات برای ماندن افغانها در المان، دیپورت را متوقف کنید!

Afghanistan ist alles andere als sicher. Seit mehr als drei Jahrzehnten sind Menschen auf der Flucht vor Terror und Krieg. Keine Abschiebungen nach Afghanistan! Demonstration am 10.12.2016, um 12:00 Uhr, U-Bahn Turmstraße, Berlin Der nun seit fast vier Jahrzehnten andauernde Krieg in Afghanistan hat 6 Millionen Menschen weltweit in die Flucht getrieben, und 2015 mehr… Read more »

afghandemo_fb
Demo / International Women's Space / News / Refugee Groups Berlin / Support/Solidarity

Tag gegen Gewalt an Frauen* Internationalistische Frauen DEMO Freitag, 25.11.2016, 16 Uhr, Turmstrasse (U9)

Organizers: Frauen * von Ezidischer FrauenRat Berlin, Frauenrat Dest Dan, International Women Space, Interkulturelle Frauenzentrum S.U.S.I, Frauen aus Rojhilat, Sozialistischer Frauenbund Berlin-SKB, Women in Exile & Friends, JXK – Studierende Frauen aus Kurdistan, FrauenRat der PYD Berlin (Rojava Frauen), Frauenrat der HDK Berlin, Lara e.V „From feminicide to selfdefence” along the motto of the current… Read more »

international-women-space-demo
german wide movement / News / refugee-struggle / Support/Solidarity / Videos

Protest March Munich to Nuremberg

8th of  October 2016, Munich 33th day at Sendlinger Tor 1st day on Protest March We need your financial support for our protest march from Munich to Nürnberg – read more about it on our web page: refugeestruggle.org Spendenkonto: Account name: Refugee Struggle for Freedom BIC: GENODEM1GLS IBAN: DE 97 4306 0967 8229 1322 00… Read more »

protest-march-2016-munchen-to-nurnberg-16

Recent

News / refugee-struggle

Roma-Black Box Solidarity – Break Deportation Aktion in Erfurt

Break Deportation Aktion in Erfurt – „Roma-Black Box Solidarity“ Roma Solidaritäts-Veranstaltung mit Diskussion und Kulturprogramm 17.12.2016, 16.00 Uhr in Erfurt, Schillerstraße 44, Filler This is the first Solidarity Event of our campaign to stop the deportation of the Roma family Haliti / Ristic Refugee activists will speak on their experiences with deportation and social exclusion… Read more »

roma-thuringen
News / refugee-struggle / the-voice-jenna

Vorbereitungstreffen für das “Break Deportation Solidarity Aktionswochenende” Januar 2017

English / Deutsch: Solidarity Aktionswochenende” im Januar 2017 Einladung zum Vorbereitungstreffen für das “Break Deportation Solidarity Aktionswochenende” im Januar 2017 Wann? Donnerstag, 08. Dezember um 18Uhr Wo? In den Räumen des Demokratischen Jugendrings (Seidelstraße 21) Jena Für das Wochenende vom 27. bis 29. Januar 2017 planen wir – das Netzwerk Break Deportation – in Jena… Read more »

break-the-deportation-culture
alle bleiben / berlin news / refugee-struggle / Support/Solidarity / Videos

Right to stay for Hikmet! Bleiberecht für Hikmet!

Hikmet’s is getting the answer about “Bleiberecht” from the “Petition Office” Dec. 1. if he doesn’t get it he is threatened with deportation. And the oldest of his two brothers is also being threatened with deportation. Wir alle hoffen jetzt auf ein “Bleiberecht”, die Anhörung ist am 1. Dezember. Inzwischen droht ihrem älteren Bruder dasselbe… Read more »

Alle bleiben Freiheit für Hikmet
berlin news / Demo / LMB - lager mobilisation berlin

The break out from the Lager at Osloerstr 23 #CloseTheCamp #LagerOsloerstr23

On the 18th November, a group went to Bezirksparlaments im Rathaus Berlin-Mitte to tell their situation, as it is shortly explained below: Besuch der BVV und des Bezirksparlaments im Rathaus Berlin-Mitte Am 18. November 2016 besuchte eine Gruppe bestehend aus asylsuchenden Menschen aus dem BTB-betriebenen Lager (Notunterkunft) und der umgebenden Nachbarschaft Weddings die Bezirksverordnetenversammlung (BVV)… Read more »

putting candles
german wide movement / News / refugee-struggle / the-voice-jenna

Break Deportation Arena and Campaign to Break the deportation Culture

Upcoming events with The VOICE Refugee Forum: Hello All, Your are invited to join us in building “Break Deportation Arena and Campaign to Break the deportation Culture” in Germany There will be open meetings of Break Deportation – Refugee Community to discuss the upcoming events in Thueringen. Starting tomorrow, on Saturday, 26.11.16 in Jena at… Read more »

the-voice-refugee-forum
refugee-struggle / Support/Solidarity

Widerstand gegen die Abschiebemaschinerie, Knäste und Grenzzäune

Hallo Genoss*innen, am 21. Februar 2016 (1) sind zehn Geflüchtete aus verschiedenen Ländern im Abschiebeknast in Mühldorf am Inn, eine kleine Stadt in der Nähe von München, in den Hungerstreik getreten, weil ihnen gegen ihre Abschiebung kein anderes Mittel blieb. Allerdings wurde ihr Protest von Medien und Politik mit Ignoranz beantwortet.Aus politischer Solidarität und als… Read more »

gefluchtete-im-hungerstreik-solidaritat-in-muhldorf